The Calculated Creative

Auditing Creativity Analytically

When wielded responsibly an audit can reveal where room for growth exists and where potential is already being effectively fulfilled.

Creativity is often seen as a mystical, unquantifiable force - the product of inspiration striking rather than cold analysis.

But while creativity does stem from the imagination, that doesn't mean it cannot or should not be examined methodically.

In fact, auditing creativity analytically can provide valuable insights while still leaving room for that creative spark.

The Benefits of an Analytical Approach

Attempting to audit creativity may seem anathema to the freewheeling spirit that creative work requires. However, bringing more rigorous examination has several key advantages that can actually improve creative outcomes rather than hinder them:

  • Spotting Trends - Detailed analytics can identify larger patterns in creative output - which specific ideas, themes, and execution styles draw audiences in most effectively, what common elements appear across multiple popular works in a genre, etc. Carefully tracking this kind of data informs content creators on what broadly resonates with their target demographics.
  • Avoiding Pitfalls - Just as analytics reveal what succeeds and connects with audiences, they can also uncover what fails to land or actively alienates. Auditing creative work allows creators to clearly identify blind spots, weaknesses, and mistakes that should be avoided - improving quality control.
  • Inspiring Innovation - When metrics provide a clear picture of what's been overdone in the past, creators can intentionally explore totally new directions rather than retreading the same ground. Understanding the full scope of what's come before allows innovators to leap further.
  • Capturing Lightning in a Bottle - Moments of sudden inspiration are often fleeting - that spark of an idea that feels exciting in the moment may fade quickly from memory. However by evaluating even unsuccessful creative work, analytics allow you to revisit and appreciate where potential exists even after the initial fire of inspiration fades.

An Analytical Toolkit for Evaluating Creativity

Approaching creativity analytically requires consistent conceptual frameworks - classifications and categories that allow comparison - as well as measurement tools providing insights numerical or otherwise. Some examples of useful methods include:

  • Qualitative Coding Frameworks - Coming up with a defined coding scheme for labeling creative work based on themes, styles, structure provides standardized metadata. This allows spotting patterns across a corpus even when the expression is unstructured or hard to quantify directly. Codes can cover everything from emotional sentiment to symbolism.
  • **Idea Generation Heuristics ** - Simple principles like forcing connections of disparate concepts and perspectives, listing as many ideas as possible before judging quality, intentionally eliminating initial self-censorship and blocks all provide rules of thumb that encourage imagination to flow freely. These analytic frameworks indirectly stimulate raw ideation.
  • Scoring Creativity and Innovation - While defining what constitutes innovation can be slippery with lots of caveats, some metrics do provide directional guidance. Novelty, uniqueness compared to current and historical examples and practices, and depth of influence/impact give a starting rubric for quantifying innovation potential.
  • Diffusion Analysis - Analytics like cluster mapping creations that gain traction, viral coefficient calculations demonstrating organic share rates, and data mining reactions can reveal how new ideas spread through a target culture and community. This highlights the most effective innovations by quantifying influence.

Optimizing Rather Than Overseeing Creativity

The ultimate goal in analytically auditing creativity should not be strict oversight or by-the-book scorekeeping on creative work.

When wielded responsibly an audit can reveal where room for growth exists and where potential is already being effectively fulfilled.

The data, categories, and metrics extracted should guide and expand boundaries - not enforce constrain them.

With the right flexible, dynamically updated analytical approach creativity and analytics thus not only coexist but can actively thrive together.

Make Your Work
Suck Less

Pulling back the curtain on the creative process to help make your work a little less terrible. A 3-minute read delivered each week on Monday morning.

The Calculated Creative

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to The Calculated Creative.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.